Summary of Judgments on Disputes Regarding Paternity Determination in Vietnam
Summary of Judgments on Disputes Regarding Paternity Determination in Vietnam
Table of contents:
- I. Judgment No. 135/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated August 27, 2026: Lawsuit Procedures for Establishing Paternity When Another Person is Registered on the Birth Certificate
- 1. General Overview of the Dispute
- 2. Factual Background of the Case
- 3. Submissions and Arguments of the Parties before the Court
- 4. Court Ruling and Legal Assessment
- II. Judgment No. 368/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated August 24, 2026: Settlement of Dispute over Paternity Determination and Child Support Obligations upon Refusal of DNA Testing
- 1. Case Summary
- 2. Factual Background and Origin of Child Support Obligations
- 3. Arguments of the Parties and Views of Procedural Authorities
- 4. Legal Findings of the Court
- 5. Court Ruling
- III. Judgment No. 32/HNGĐ-ST dated May 27, 2026: Settlement of Dispute over Paternity Determination and Birth Certificate Amendment Procedures upon Availability of DNA Results
- 1. Case Summary
- 2. Factual Background
- 3. Arguments of the Parties and Views of Procedural Authorities
- 4. Legal Findings of the Court
- 5. Court Ruling
- IV. Judgment No. 1302/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated June 30, 2026: Childbirth with Another Person during Separation
I. Judgment No. 135/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated August 27, 2026: Lawsuit Procedures for Establishing Paternity When Another Person is Registered on the Birth Certificate
1. General Overview of the Dispute
-
Adjudicating Court: People's Court of Regional District 5 – Hung Yen Province.
-
Subject Matter of Dispute: Marriage and family case regarding the "Establishment of Paternity" (Determination of Father-Child Relationship).
2. Factual Background of the Case
-
Mr. Nguyen Thach C and Ms. Nguyen Thi Kieu O previously maintained an emotional relationship and cohabited as husband and wife without registering their marriage. They subsequently separated; Ms. O gave birth to the child Nguyen Phu H1 (born on May 27, 2011) without notifying Mr. C.
-
In 2015, Ms. O married Mr. Nguyen Hoang Minh T. Despite knowing that the child H1 was not his biological child, Mr. T agreed to be registered as the father in Birth Certificate No. 410/2014 (late registration dated December 29, 2014, at the People's Committee of D Commune, D District, Thai Binh Province – currently D Commune, Hung Yen Province).
-
Ms. O and Mr. T had two other common children. Following irreconcilable domestic conflicts, the parties divorced pursuant to First-Instance Marriage and Family Judgment No. 05/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated January 12, 2026 (which only resolved matters concerning the two common children without addressing the parentage of child H1). Following the divorce, Ms. O informed Mr. C that child H1 was his biological offspring.
-
Mr. C and Ms. O underwent DNA testing at C2 Joint Stock Company. Forensic Assessment Conclusion No. 260807.24 dated August 7, 2026 confirmed: Mr. Nguyen Thach C is the biological father of child Nguyen Phu H1 with a probability of 99.9999%. Because the Birth Certificate officially listed Mr. T as the father, the parties could not perform administrative amendments at civil status registration authorities and were required to file a lawsuit petitioning the Court for judicial determination.
3. Submissions and Arguments of the Parties before the Court
-
The Plaintiff (Mr. Nguyen Thach C): Affirmed that child H1 is his biological child based on DNA Assessment Conclusion No. 260807.24; petitioned the Court to legally recognize the father-child relationship; voluntarily assumed all DNA testing costs; waived conciliation/mediation, and submitted a petition for trial in absentia.
-
The Defendant (Ms. Nguyen Thi Kieu O): Confirmed the full veracity of Mr. C’s testimony; acknowledged that child H1 is the common biological child of herself and Mr. C; consented to the plaintiff’s claims; agreed to Mr. C bearing the testing fees; waived mediation, and requested trial in absentia.
-
Person with Related Rights and Obligations (Mr. Nguyen Hoang Minh T): Confirmed that child H1 is not his biological child and that his prior registration on the birth certificate arose from marital goodwill upon marrying Ms. O; fully concurred with Mr. C’s petition; requested the Court to adjudicate according to statutory provisions, and requested trial in absentia.
-
Opinion of the Representative of the People's Procuracy of Regional District 5 – Hung Yen:
-
Regarding procedural matters: The Judge, the Trial Panel, and the involved parties strictly adhered to the statutory provisions of the Civil Procedure Code.
-
Regarding substantive matters: Recommended that the Court grant the plaintiff’s claims in their entirety pursuant to the Law on Marriage and Family, and consider granting Mr. C an exemption from paying court fee advances and first-instance court fees as prescribed by law.
-
4. Court Ruling and Legal Assessment
Legal Assessment of the Trial Panel:
-
On jurisdiction and procedural compliance: The dispute falls within the territorial jurisdiction of the People's Court of Regional District 5 – Hung Yen Province according to the defendant's place of residence. The joint submissions by all parties waiving mediation and petitioning for trial in absentia fulfilled all legal prerequisites for the Court to conduct the hearing in absentia under Articles 227, 228, and 238 of the Civil Procedure Code.
-
On the substantive merits of the claim: DNA Assessment Conclusion No. 260807.24 bears conclusive evidentiary value (99.9999% statistical certainty), which aligns consistently with the statements of all involved parties. Consequently, the lawsuit petitioning for paternity establishment filed by Mr. C is well-founded pursuant to the Law on Marriage and Family.
Court Decision:
-
Grant the plaintiff’s petition in its entirety: Legally determine that Mr. Nguyen Thach C is the biological father of child Nguyen Phu H1 (born on May 27, 2011, to mother Nguyen Thi Kieu O). Mr. C and Ms. O are entitled and obligated to contact the competent civil status registration agency to carry out procedures for civil status correction and modification of paternity information on child H1’s Birth Certificate.
-
Procedural Costs: Formally acknowledge the voluntary undertaking of Mr. Nguyen Thach C to cover all DNA assessment costs (which have been fully paid).
II. Judgment No. 368/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated August 24, 2026: Settlement of Dispute over Paternity Determination and Child Support Obligations upon Refusal of DNA Testing
1. Case Summary
-
Adjudicating Court: Regional People's Court 16 – Ho Chi Minh City (Judgment No.: 368/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated August 24, 2026).
-
Dispute Relation: "Dispute over determination of father for child and child support claim."
2. Factual Background and Origin of Child Support Obligations
In 2021, Ms. G and Mr. M were in a romantic relationship and had a baby boy born on November 18, 2022, at Gia Dinh People's Hospital (intended name: Tran Minh Tr). Because the father had not been legally established under statutory regulations, the child’s birth registration was temporarily left pending.
On January 15, 2024, at the Citizen Reception Office of the Police of D City (Binh Duong Province), Mr. Tong Minh M attended a working session in person, acknowledged his father-son relationship with child Tran Minh Tr, and agreed to fulfill a monthly child support obligation of VND 3,000,000.
However, starting in December 2025, Mr. M unilaterally ceased child support payments and evaded further cooperation. Consequently, Ms. G officially filed a lawsuit before Regional People's Court 16 – Ho Chi Minh City.
3. Arguments of the Parties and Views of Procedural Authorities
-
Plaintiff (Ms. G): Requested the Court to recognize Mr. M as the biological father of child Tr; concurrently petitioned for child support of VND 3,000,000 per month until the child reaches 18 years of age, or alternatively requested a lump-sum payment totaling VND 648,000,000.
-
Defendant (Mr. M): Acknowledged the romantic relationship and admitted to the prior minutes acknowledging paternity executed at the Police of D City. However, during judicial proceedings, Mr. M submitted a written refusal to undergo court-ordered DNA testing.
-
Representative of the People's Procuracy: Recommended that the Trial Panel partially accept the plaintiff’s claims.
4. Legal Findings of the Court
-
On paternity determination in the absence of DNA testing: Although Mr. M refused DNA testing, the case records and documentary evidence (notably the Working Minutes dated January 15, 2024, at the Police of D City) demonstrate that Mr. M voluntarily acknowledged child Tran Minh Tr as his biological child. Pursuant to Article 91 of the 2014 Law on Marriage and Family, this acknowledgement constitutes a solid legal ground for the Court to grant the petition for paternity determination.
-
On the child support obligation: The claimed amount of VND 3,000,000 per month is reasonable, commensurate with the child’s essential needs and the defendant's actual earning capacity (in compliance with Article 82 and Article 116 of the Law on Marriage and Family). The alternative claim for a lump-sum payment (VND 648 million) was denied because the defendant did not consent and such a lump sum is inconsistent with his periodic financial capacity.
5. Court Ruling
-
Partially accepted the plaintiff’s petition: Recognized Mr. Tong Minh M as the biological father of the male child born on November 18, 2022 (intended name: Tran Minh Tr).
-
Child support obligation: Compelled Mr. Tong Minh M to pay monthly child support in the amount of VND 3,000,000, calculated from the effective date of the judgment until child Tr reaches full 18 years of age.
-
First-instance court fees: Mr. Tong Minh M shall bear VND 600,000 in first-instance marriage and family court fees.
III. Judgment No. 32/HNGĐ-ST dated May 27, 2026: Settlement of Dispute over Paternity Determination and Birth Certificate Amendment Procedures upon Availability of DNA Results
1. Case Summary
-
Adjudicating Court: Regional People's Court 3 – Ho Chi Minh City (Judgment No.: 32/HNGĐ-ST dated May 27, 2026).
-
Dispute Relation: "Dispute over determination of father for child."
2. Factual Background
Ms. Pham Tu A and Mr. Huynh Han Q were in a romantic relationship from 2020 until their separation in March 2022 (at which point Ms. A was unaware of her pregnancy). Ms. A subsequently married Mr. Nguyen Le Hoang P on December 28, 2022. Prior to that marriage, on November 19, 2022, Ms. A gave birth to a baby boy named Nguyen Hoang K at Hung Vuong Hospital and registered his birth certificate naming Mr. P as the father.
Noticing that the child did not resemble the married couple but bore a strong resemblance to Mr. Q, the family voluntarily conducted a DNA test in March 2023, which concluded that child K is the biological child of Mr. Q. This event led to a divorce between Ms. A and Mr. P. During the judicial proceedings, the Trial Panel commissioned an official forensic DNA examination, which conclusively confirmed that child Nguyen Hoang K is the biological son of Mr. Huynh Han Q.
3. Arguments of the Parties and Views of Procedural Authorities
-
Plaintiff and Defendant: Both petitioned the Court to recognize Mr. Huynh Han Q as the biological father of child Nguyen Hoang K to protect the child's lawful rights and interests and to regularize personal civil status documents. Both parties submitted requests for trial in absentia.
-
Person with Related Rights and Obligations (Mr. P): Absent without legitimate grounds despite being lawfully summoned and having notices legally posted.
-
Representative of the People's Procuracy: Recommended that the Trial Panel grant the plaintiff’s petition in its entirety, determine Mr. Q as the biological father of child K, and grant an exemption from court fees in accordance with statutory regulations.
4. Legal Findings of the Court
-
On paternity determination: Although child K was born during the legal marriage between Ms. A and Mr. P (subject to the statutory presumption of parentage under Article 88 of the 2014 Law on Marriage and Family), the lawful DNA test result commissioned during proceedings conclusively established that Mr. Huynh Han Q is the biological father, consistent with the mutual acknowledgments of the litigants. The legal redetermination of paternity is necessary to safeguard the lawful rights and interests of the child.
-
On court fees: The plaintiff is granted full exemption from court fee advances and first-instance civil court fees pursuant to Resolution No. 326/2016/UBTVQH14 regarding disputes on parentage determination for minors.
5. Court Ruling
-
Fully accepted the lawsuit claims: Determined Mr. Huynh Han Q to be the biological father of child Nguyen Hoang K (born November 19, 2022).
-
Right to civil status adjustment: Ms. Pham Tu A and Mr. Huynh Han Q are entitled to contact the competent civil registry authority to amend child K’s birth certificate by replacing the recorded father's name (Nguyen Le Hoang P) with the biological father's name (Huynh Han Q), and to update all relevant personal identity records.
-
Court fees: Fully exempted the plaintiff from first-instance civil court fees.
IV. Judgment No. 1302/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated June 30, 2026: Childbirth with Another Person during Separation
1. General Case Overview
-
Adjudicating Court: Regional People's Court 9 – Ho Chi Minh City (Judgment No.: 1302/2026/HNGĐ-ST dated June 30, 2026; Case Docket No.: 842/2026/TLST-HNGĐ dated May 8, 2026).
-
Dispute Relation: Dispute over determination of parents for child.
-
Composition of Procedural Authorities:
-
Judge – Presiding Judge: Mr. Pham Viet Hai
-
People's Assessors: Ms. Nguyen Thi Cam, Mr. Nguyen Manh Tuong
-
Court Clerk: Ms. Le Thi Kim Cuong
-
Representative of Regional People's Procuracy 9 – HCMC: Ms. Nguyen Thi Anh Tuyet
-
-
Litigants: Plaintiff, Defendant, and Person with Related Rights and Obligations.
2. Civil Status Developments and Origin of Claims
-
Prior marriage and childbirth during wedlock: Ms. Doan Thi B M and Mr. Truong V T were previously legally married (registered at the People's Committee of Commune F, District G, City H, with 01 common child). The couple separated in 2019 and officially finalized their divorce pursuant to Decision No. 587/2026/QĐST-HNGĐ dated April 13, 2026, issued by Regional People's Court 10 – HCMC.
-
Non-marital cohabitation and the statutory presumption: During her separation from Mr. T, Ms. M cohabited without marriage registration with Mr. Tran Dang T P. Ms. M subsequently gave birth to a baby boy (intended name: Doan T P1, according to the Birth Certification issued by Hospital J). Because the child was born while Ms. M and Mr. T were still legally married (the divorce had not yet been finalized at the time of birth), under the statutory presumption in Clause 1, Article 88 of the 2014 Law on Marriage and Family, the child was deemed prima facie to be the common child of Mr. T and Ms. M.
-
DNA test results and legal proceedings: Both Ms. M and Mr. T affirmed that the boy is not their common child. DNA Test Report No. KQ dated June 4, 2026, issued by Z Genetic Analysis Services Joint Stock Company, concluded that the boy and Mr. Tran Dang T P share a biological father-son relationship. Given that the child was preparing to enter first grade and needed regularized civil identity documents for school admission, Ms. M filed a lawsuit requesting the Court to legally recognize Mr. P as the child's biological father.
3. Arguments of the Litigants and Procuracy Opinion
-
Plaintiff (Ms. Doan Thi B M): Requested the Court to determine Mr. Tran Dang T P as the biological father of the boy (intended name: Doan T P1); agreed with the DNA results, voluntarily undertook all forensic costs, and petitioned for trial in absentia.
-
Defendant (Mr. Tran Dang T P): Acknowledged his cohabitation period with Ms. M and agreed with the DNA analysis confirming a biological father-son relationship; raised no counterclaims or objections to the plaintiff's petition, requested the Court to resolve the matter in accordance with the law, and requested trial in absentia.
-
Person with Related Rights and Obligations (Mr. Truong V T): Affirmed that the boy is not his and Ms. M's child; concurred with the DNA test results, asserted no other claims, and requested to be absent throughout the entire judicial proceedings.
-
Representative of Regional People's Procuracy 9 – HCMC:
-
Procedurally: The Court properly adhered to the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code concerning subject-matter jurisdiction and statutory procedures.
-
Substantively: Recommended that the Trial Panel accept the plaintiff’s petition in full, determining Mr. Tran Dang T P as the biological father of the child.
-
4. Court Ruling and Legal Findings
-
Legal Findings of the Court:
-
Jurisdiction and procedure: The case falls under the territorial jurisdiction of Regional People's Court 9 – Ho Chi Minh City based on the defendant's place of residence (Clause 4 Article 28, Point a Clause 1 Article 35, Point a Clause 1 Article 39 of the Civil Procedure Code and Amending Law No. 85/2025/QH15). The Trial Panel conducted the hearing in absentia for all litigants pursuant to their written applications under Clause 1, Article 228 of the Civil Procedure Code. Joining Mr. T as a person with related rights and obligations complies with civil procedure rules to ensure a comprehensive resolution.
-
Grounds for redetermining paternity: Although the child was born during the legal marriage between Ms. M and Mr. T (triggering the legal presumption of a common child under Clause 1, Article 88 of the 2014 Law on Marriage and Family), both Ms. M and Mr. T mutually and consistently admitted that the child is not their common child (recorded under Clause 2, Article 92 of the Civil Procedure Code). The legally obtained DNA analysis result from an accredited entity confirming that Mr. P shares a biological father-son relationship with the child constitutes objective, scientific evidence with probative force (Articles 94, 95, and 108 of the Civil Procedure Code). Therefore, the plaintiff’s claim has established legal grounds pursuant to Article 89, Clause 2 Article 101, and Article 102 of the 2014 Law on Marriage and Family.
-
-
Court Decision:
-
Fully accepted the lawsuit petition of plaintiff Ms. Doan Thi B M: Determined Mr. Tran Dang T P (born January 17, 1989; Personal Identification No.: 079089009018) as the biological father of the male child (intended name: Doan T P1, born pursuant to the Birth Certification issued by Hospital J).
-
Expert assessment costs: Formally recorded that Ms. M voluntarily bears the entirety of the genetic testing costs paid to Z Genetic Analysis Services Joint Stock Company.
-
First-instance court fees: Ms. Doan Thi B M shall bear VND 300,000 in first-instance civil court fees (deducted from the advance payment of VND 300,000 already remitted under receipt dated May 4, 2026; Ms. M has fully discharged this liability).
-
Right to appeal: The absent litigants are entitled to lodge an appeal against this judgment within 15 days from the date of receipt of the judgment or from the date the judgment is lawfully posted
-
The information contained in this article is general and intended only to provide information on legal regulations. DB Legal will not be responsible for any use or application of this information for any business purpose. For in-depth advice on specific cases, please contact us.
For more information:
Related posts:
- Slander and Insulting Others on Social Media – When Does It Constitute a Criminal Offense?
- Compilation of Judgments on Apartment Sale and Purchase Contract Disputes
- Summary of Judgments on Disputes Arising from Sale of Goods Contracts with Foreign Elements
- Compilation of Labor Disputes Involving Foreign Employees
- Guide on Calculating Late Payment Interest under Article 306 of the Commercial Law (Through Trial Practice)
- Procedures for resolving civil cases and matters with foreign elements: A detailed guide under Vietnamese law
- Civil Judgment Enforcement Procedures: Latest Jurisdiction & Sequence
- Civil Judgment Enforcement Competence of Bailiffs
- Prohibited Acts in Civil Judgment Enforcement in Vietnam
- Judgments and Decisions Enforceable in Vietnam: Latest Updates
.png)


