Family Lawyers in Vietnam

When Elderly Parents Become Frail and Lose Cognitive Capacity: Who Has the Right to Manage and Dispose of Their Assets?

In many families, when parents reach old age, experience declining health, and lose mental clarity, children often step in to manage finances, property documents, or conduct transactions on their parents' behalf. This care and support stem from family affection and responsibility. However, the boundary between "helping parents manage their assets" and "unilaterally disposing of parents' assets" is a legal issue that requires particular attention.

1. Old age and frail health do not mean losing the right to dispose of assets

The law does not automatically strip a person of their right to self-determination simply because they are elderly, ill, or in need of care. If parents remain cognitively aware and able to control their actions, they retain the right to own, possess, use, and dispose of their assets. Children do not automatically gain the right to sell a house, transfer land, withdraw savings, or gift assets merely because they are directly caring for their parents.

Article 158 of the 2015 Civil Code defines ownership rights as comprising the right to possess, the right to use, and the right to dispose of property. These rights belong to the owner, except where otherwise provided by law. Therefore, it is necessary to accurately determine the parents' civil act capacity status before conducting any asset-related transactions.

2. When is a person declared to lack civil act capacity?

Under Article 22 of the 2015 Civil Code, when a person is unable to comprehend or control their actions due to a mental illness or another ailment, at the request of a person with related rights or interests, or of a relevant agency or organization, the Court may issue a decision declaring that person to lack civil act capacity based on a forensic psychiatric examination conclusion.

Thus, parents becoming forgetful, experiencing intermittent confusion, suffering a stroke, developing dementia, or having age-related illnesses does not automatically give rise to a status of lacking civil act capacity. A prescribed expert examination conclusion and a Court decision are required. This serves as the crucial legal basis for establishing guardianship and representation.

Article 22 also stipulates that when the grounds for declaring a person to lack civil act capacity no longer exist, that person themselves, a person with related rights or interests, or a relevant agency or organization may request the Court to revoke its previous declaration decision. This provision aims to safeguard human rights and prevent a person from facing prolonged restrictions on their civil rights once their health condition has changed.

3. Who has the right to guardianship and asset management?

Once the Court has declared a father or mother to lack civil act capacity, that person requires a guardian in accordance with the law. Article 46 of the 2015 Civil Code defines guardianship as the arrangement whereby an individual or legal entity prescribed by law, appointed, or designated cares for and protects the lawful rights and interests of the ward.

The order of natural guardians for an adult lacking civil act capacity is determined under Article 53 of the Civil Code. First is the spouse; if there is no spouse or the spouse does not meet the eligibility conditions, the eldest child becomes the guardian; if the eldest child does not meet the conditions, the next eligible child assumes the role. In cases where there is no eligible spouse or child to act as guardian, the parents serve as the guardians. If there is no natural guardian, the People's Committee of the commune where the ward resides is responsible for appointing a guardian in accordance with statutory procedures.

A guardian is obligated to provide care, ensure medical treatment, represent the ward in civil transactions, and manage their assets. However, guardianship does not mean the guardian becomes the owner of the assets. Houses, land, savings deposits, shares, or other assets still belong to the parents; the guardian may only exercise rights within the scope permitted by law and for the benefit of the ward.

4. Is a guardian permitted to unilaterally sell or gift their parents' house and land?

This is the issue most prone to disputes, particularly when parents have multiple children or high-value assets. Article 59 of the 2015 Civil Code governs the management of a ward's property: the guardian must manage the ward's property as if it were their own; may conduct transactions involving the property for the benefit of the ward; and any sale, exchange, lease, lending, loan, pledge, mortgage, deposit, or other transaction involving high-value property must obtain the consent of the guardianship supervisor.

For a ward who lacks civil act capacity, transactions involving assets must serve the essential needs and lawful interests of that very person. Guardians must not abuse their position to transfer assets into their own name, gift them to relatives, or use their parents' money for personal purposes. Transactions carrying a risk of conflict of interest must be scrutinized with particular caution and must comply with the limits of representation under the Civil Code.

Example: Mr. A has been declared by the Court to lack civil act capacity and owns a single house that secures his accommodation and care expenses. The child designated as his guardian cannot unilaterally sign a contract gifting the house to themselves or selling it to divide the proceeds among siblings. If the disposition of the asset is not intended to serve Mr. A's interests, the transaction may be disputed and have its legal validity reviewed in accordance with the law.

5. How can transactions established by a person who has lost cognitive capacity be handled?

Not every document signed by an elderly person results in an automatically invalid transaction. It is necessary to examine their state of cognitive awareness and ability to control their actions at the exact time the transaction was established, the content of the transaction, medical evidence, and related documents.

Article 125 of the 2015 Civil Code governs civil transactions that are invalid due to being established or performed by minors, persons lacking civil act capacity, persons with difficulties in cognition and behavior control, or persons with restricted civil act capacity. The application of this article must be based accurately on the legal status of the transacting party and the exceptions prescribed by law.

Additionally, Article 128 of the 2015 Civil Code regulates cases where a person possesses civil act capacity but, at the time of establishing a transaction, is unable to comprehend and control their actions. When sufficient grounds exist, persons with related rights or interests may petition the Court to declare the transaction invalid. The legal consequences of an invalid transaction are addressed under Article 131 of the Civil Code: the parties shall restore the original state and return to one another what they have received; the party at fault causing damage must pay compensation as prescribed by law.

Therefore, if a family discovers that their parents were taken to a notary office to sign a transfer contract, execute a will, or sign a power of attorney during a period when they lacked cognitive capacity, the family should promptly gather medical records, specialist conclusions, notarization dossiers, witness statements, and evidence of money transfers to protect their lawful rights.

6. What can be done to protect parents' assets and rights?

First and foremost, the family must respect their parents' right to self-determination while they still retain cognitive awareness and control over their actions. If their health shows signs of serious decline, the family should take them for medical examination and treatment and retain all medical records. When sufficient grounds indicate that they can no longer comprehend or control their actions, persons with related interests may petition the Court to declare them lacking civil act capacity following proper procedures.

Once a Court decision is obtained, the family should identify the lawful guardian, implement guardianship supervision, and manage assets transparently. An inventory of assets should be compiled, and land use right certificates, savings passbooks, ownership documents, and income/expense receipts should be securely kept. Major transactions must be carefully weighed, backed by evidence proving they serve the parents' interests, and compliant with the requirement for the guardianship supervisor's consent.

If there are signs of misappropriation, coercion to sign documents, signature forgery, or unauthorized transfer of assets, relatives may submit petitions to competent authorities, request appropriate legal remedies, or file a lawsuit to protect ownership rights. Criminal denunciation should only be pursued when the conduct exhibits sufficient elements constituting a crime; ordinary family property disputes should not be conflated with criminal offenses.

7. Conclusion

Parents' assets are the fruits of a lifetime of labor and accumulation. When parents become frail and lose cognitive capacity, what matters is not only who steps forward to manage their assets, but how those assets are managed to safeguard the livelihood, safety, and lawful wishes of the owners themselves. The law grants guardianship authority to protect vulnerable individuals—not to create an opportunity for anyone to appropriate or dispose of their assets for personal gain.

 

The information contained in this article is general and intended only to provide information on legal regulations. DB Legal will not be responsible for any use or application of this information for any business purpose. For in-depth advice on specific cases, please contact us.

For more information:

 

Contact us

Add 1: 3rd Floor, Indochina Riverside Tower, 81 Tran Phu Street, Hai Chau Ward, Danang City, Vietnam

Add 2: 28 Thanh Luong 20, Hoa Xuan Ward,  Danang city, Vietnam

Hotline 1: (+84) 357 466 579

Hotline 2: (+84) 985 271 242

Phone: (+84) 236.366.4674
Email: contact@dblegal.vn

zalo
whatsapp